Year: 2017

Through their first 10 games, only 18 goals. They’ve since scored 13 goals in two games, but that is probably more of an anomaly than a new trend. In reality, it’s no secret, this team can’t score. What’s worse, they only have 4 wins through 12 games. To put it mildly, the season does not look good so far.

If you look at the team stats, Drouin leads the way with 9 points through 12 games. Brendan Gallagher leads in the goal department with 4. Is it time to hit the panic button yet? I believe, it should have been pushed a couple years ago.

Looking back at the 2015-16 season, the Habs finished with a mediocre 38-38-6 record. Carey Price played 12 games, and no one on the team played with better than a +4 in the +/- category. Read into that what you will, but the Habs missed the playoffs and only finished better in the Atlantic than the rebuilding Leafs and Sabres. Not something to be proud of for a team that should have been a no-brainer playoff team. Either way, that season alone should have been the point when they hit panic button.

Looking at the last 10 cup winners, only 2 of them had a goalie win the Conn Smythe. Even then, I would argue that one of them probably was given to the wrong guy. Not that they didn’t play great, but in my opinion, they weren’t their team’s best player during their run. With that said, it’s hard to be a cup champion when your best player is your goalie. It takes a great system, solid D, and timely saves. Looking at where the league has been trending the last few years, your team’s best player needs to be the center. As a goalie, that’s hard for me to admit, but when you look at your team on paper, you should be able to say that the number 1 center is the best player or close to it. The Hab’s number 1 center, Drouin, would be hard to argue as the number 2 or 3rd best player on that team. And he is even a true center. He has played his entire NHL career in Tampa on the wing.

For a team that has so much trouble scoring, and it’s been no secret for a few years, their highest paid player should not be the goalie. You cannot rely on Price to carry the team every year. If he plays average (this year for example) or even above average, this team will struggle to get into the playoffs. Not to mention, the D in front of him is poor. One of the worst groups of 6/7 D-men in the league. Now, did Carey Price deserve the money he got on his contract extension? Yes. If there was ever a guy that could easily be a team’s MVP, it’s Price. They have relied too much on him to carry the team, and when he was injured or while he’s playing average this year, it shows in the win column. What the Habs should have done, was deal Price before his extension was signed and finish a rebuild.

Now yes, Price’s current deal at $6.5 mil, does have a modified NTC. This would have restricted the ability to trade him to 15 teams of Price’s choosing, which likely would not have been bottom-of-the-league teams. Looking at the remaining teams, who could and would have traded for Price? Perhaps Dallas, Winnipeg, the Islanders, Flyers, or Calgary? This is assuming the Habs move Price at the draft this past year after the Habs won the division and Price’s value was very high. So what could they have gotten in return? Start with Travis Hamonic for example.

The Islanders received a first and 2 seconds for a top-4 defenseman. For the teams listed above, their need for a quality goalie would definitely have gotten the Habs a greater return. We’re talking multiple first rounders, a prospect, and a quality NHL roster defenseman/center. Take for example the Flyers. Now while I like Brian Elliott, Carey Price is clearly a big upgrade. The Flyers could have moved the 2017 first rounder (#27 pick acquired in the Blues trade), one of their 2018 first rounders, another mid rounder and/or a prospect, and perhaps Sean Couturier? Looking at this current year, Couturier has been good in their number 1 center role, but Philly has an abundance of centers and moving Couturier may not have hurt as much with the return coming their way. Not to mention, the arrival of Patrick Nolan would have eased that trade for the fans.

Now, this is all hypothetical, but looking at what Couturier is doing with Vorachek, being able to put Drouin on the wing would have been a better fit for the Habs, as he continues to grow. Not to mention, Couturier is capable of handling the defensive aspect of a number 1 role. So with Price out of Montreal, where do they turn in goal? Montoya is a great backup, but not a number 1. Looking at available free agents; Bernier, Elliot, or Mason would have been good options. Obviously a downgrade in goal, but a definite upgrade at the center position. Would this have been worth it? Yes.

At this point, you’re looking to rebuild on the fly. You acquire a capable number one center, you now have Drouin (a potential 30 to 40 goal scoring winger), and now some future pieces in prospects or draft picks. You could also use those extra draft picks along with Galchenyuk, to flip for a top-4 defensman, something Montreal desperately needs. Again, these are all hypotheticals, but it gives you options to rebuild quickly. Either way, now you don’t have to spend $10.5 million a year on a goalie, which is going to hinder their ability to lock down a number one center or other big goal scorers in the future. Plain and simple, your goalie cannot be the highest paid player on the team.

For me the answer was simple last year, Price should have been traded.

Each week, Overtime Hockey Talk will compile the best headlines and articles from around the league for each team. The order has significance, as it will follow the league standings from top to bottom. In this week’s case, the St. Louis Blues get the honor after their 4-0 start.

  • St Louis Blue – A great start can be your ticket to the playoffs (see 2016-17 Columbus Blue Jackets). It was easy to pick the St. Louis Blues to fall in the Central after losing Robbie Fabbri, and not having made any external acquisitions of note♪ over the offseason. The Blues will have to rely heavily on Jake Allen (which is great for children’s cancer research), but this Blues team looks pretty real, especially Tarasenko…[Bleed In Blue]

  • Chicago Blackhawks – No other team has made more adjustments to their defensive core than the Chicago Blackhawks. Niklas Hjalmarsson, Brian Campbell and Trevor van Riemsdyk are all gone, leaving head coach Joel Quenneville some work to figure out who pairs well together. Connor Murphy being scratched for Cody Franson is a situation to keep eyes on. [Chicago Tribune]

  • New Jersey Devils –  The Devils are 3-0 and doing it in such a way that is very un-Devils-like by scoring 16 goals in those 3 games. They look fast & exciting and Cory Schneider looks like he’s worked hard to return to form. All that said, former Devil’s goaltender and analyst Chico Resch has come out of retirement and returned to the broadcast booth and he’s on Twitter. If you haven’t seen #ChicoEats, you’re missing out…[Twitter]

  • Vegas Golden Knights – No one expected to this team to win their first three games but let’s not get ahead of ourselves. They beat an Arizona Coyotes team that looks to be a mess right now. However, the story that may effect this team long-term is the fact that Vadim Shipachyov, Shea Theodore and Alex Tuch have all been sent to the minors because GM George McPhee hasn’t been able to move all the extra defensemen (9 on the active roster with Clayton Stoner on IR) that he took during the expansion draft. Shipachyov wasn’t happy about it and McPhee apparently waited until after the fact to explain why he did it. Yikes. [Knights on Ice]

  • Colorado Avalanche – Nail Yakupov has seen early success playing on a line with Matt Duchene and Alex Kerfoot, but what if the Avs finally trade Duchene? For now, it’s good to see the biggest bust of the salary cap era leading his team in scoring with 3 goals and 2 assists, already matching last season’s goal totals with the Blues. Maybe he can avoid  [Denver Post]

  • Toronto Maple Leafs – The Leafs have been off to a torrid offensive start becoming the first team since the 92-93 Penguins to score 18 goals in the first 3 games. But in the battle of the last two year’s #1 overall picks, Nico Hischier’s Devils exposed the Leafs defense with a relentless and speed-driven forecheck. The Devils even scored a shorthanded goal on a 5 on 3 penalty kill! Later in the 5 on 3 though there should’ve been a cross checking penalty, but the ref decided against it…
  • Calgary Flames – Jaromir Jagr is back in the NHL, this time with the Flames. His first game was uneventful and he said that he didn’t feel he had his legs back yet, but he’s just made the Flames a go-to when deciding which west-coast game to watch. Here’s a great picture created by in honor of Jagr playing for his ninth NHL franchise…

  • Los Angeles Kings – Dustin Brown has 5 points in 3 games playing with Anze Kopitar again and Kings fans are going nuts about it. I’m sorry but no, this isn’t a resurrection of the Stanley Cup days, the Kings are not on the rise yet, and I don’t expect Brown to be anywhere close to a point per game player. Will gladly admit to being wrong if this is still happening at the 30 game mark though! [CBS Sports]

  • Anaheim Ducks – Antoine Vermette, unhappy with a linesman’s placement of the puck on a faceoff (that’s my only explanation) decided it’d be a great idea to slash the linesman in the leg. It wasn’t nearly as violent as it sounds but it’s got to be the most out of left field player to be suspended I’ve witnessed. Have a nice 10 days off, Antoine! [Pucks of a Feather]

  • Pittsburgh Penguins – Ever wonder why the Capitals just can’t seem to beat the Penguins? [Pens Labyrinth]

  • Washington Capitals – If the Caps have a weakness, it’s their inability to stay out of the penalty box. They took the third most penalties in the league last year and have continued that trend with 20 penalties in their first four games. There’s no excuses for the new slashing enforcement either because every other team has to adjust too! [Washington Post]

  • Columbus Blue Jackets – It’s always hilarious when fans think that referees are out to get their team. Referees in the NHL are the best (one of the best blogs for former referees is Paul Stewart). They don’t care who wins a random regular season game. They call it based on what they see and sometimes, they’re going to miss calls. They’re human beings. [Union and Blue]

  • Tampa Bay Lightning – If there was one positive from last season’s debacle of a season, it was Brayden Point. He looks really good and a deep Tampa team is even more dangerous with him in it. [Tampa Bay Times]

  • Detroit Red Wings – If the Red Wings could somehow get a healthy Niklas Kronwall for one more year, it’d go a long way to keeping this team out of the basement and competitive for most of the year. Imagine if they can somehow find $600,000 for Andreas Athanasiou! [Hockey Buzz]

  • Ottawa Senators – Most people haven’t heard of Frederick Claesson but he’s being touted as the other Swedish d-man for the Sens. He played a career high 26:51 in a 3-2 shootout win against the Vancouver Canucks. He might be drawing comparisons to Karlsson but only because he’s from the same country and he played a lot of minutes that one time…Sens fans (and honestly any hockey fan) anxiously awaits a healthy Karlsson because he’s the reason to watch Ottawa. [Ottawa Citizen]

  • Philadelphia Flyers – Sometimes using your coaches challenge to reverse a goal isn’t the best call when you consider all the factors that play a part. Might just be better to leave it be according to the statistics. If you didn’t see our article about what should really happen to coaches when they fail at offside challenges you should check it out here!  [Hockey Graphs]

  • Vancouver Canucks – Brock Boeser was a guy a lot of people picked to contend for the Calder trophy. That’s not going to happen if he can’t get into the lineup over Derek Dorsett…[The Canuck Way]

  • Carolina Hurricanes – Can someone give an honest account as to why the Canes need to have a team in Carolina? Passionate hockey fans live in the area, but why don’t enough of them support this team by attending games? This team has a lot of promise and they’ve even won a Stanley Cup in the last 10 years but less than 7900 fans at the second home game of the year? [Charlotte Observer]

  • New York Islanders – Let’s hope the Isles can figure out this arena situation, and fast. The rumors are already flying and this team is a bottom feeder without John Tavares. [NY Post]

  • Florida Panthers – The Panthers lost too much over the offseason from a non-playoff team. My expectations for them are very low, although if they can stay healthy they may be able to stay in the playoff race for a little while. The hope would be that they can continue to get faster with the rest of the league and learn to play the speed game so that when guys like Owen Tippett are ready to come up to the NHL level, the Panthers will be ready to contend. [The Hockey Writers]

  • Dallas Stars – The Stars have one of the most dynamic lines in hockey with Tyler Seguin between Jamie Benn and Alexander Radulov. Between the three of them, they might need to score upwards of 90 goals to get this team into the playoffs. Everyone was high on the Stars (and there’s no reason to panic) but when you stack your lines the way the Ken Hitchcock is doing with his Stars, you better be on every night. [Blackout Dallas]

  • Edmonton Oilers – Expectations of two top centers in Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl will have to wait since head coach Todd McLellan just can’t seem to separate the two. Could be a reason for the Oilers slow start. Teams will focus heavily on the top line and wait and see if anyone else can hurt them. Dylan Strome was supposed to be the answer but he looks like the same guy that played on the Islanders last season…who would’ve thought? [SportsNet]

  • Nashville Predators – Since the last guy decided didn’t want to share the limelight with Carrie Underwood, the Predators found a replacement for their regular anthem singer. But someone couldn’t decide so they just went with four. [The Tennessean]

  • Winnipeg Jets – Mark Scheifele wrote about the five toughest players he’s ever played against. The first four are pretty easy to guess (Connor, Sidney, Carey & Erik) but the fifth surprised me…[The Players Tribune]

  • Boston Bruins – The numbers don’t lie…Tukka Rask is an average NHL goaltender. [SB Nation]

  • New York Rangers – Trading Rick Nash is next to impossible unless they take back considerable salary. My assumption is NY hangs onto him and let’s him sign elsewhere via free agency. I couldn’t see Nash fetching more than a second or third round pick. [Blue Line Station]

  • Montreal Canadiens – When you sign a 7/8 defenseman and expect him to replace Andrei Markov, this happens…[A Winning Habit]

  • Minnesota Wild – Is it their lack of star power or Bruce Boudreau that makes me doubt a long playoff run is in store for this team? They’re fun to watch and I want them to succeed because of it, but its hard to forget the past. Boudreau doesn’t win in the playoffs. All that said, “measuring stick” games in the beginning of the regular season are silly. [Twin Cities]

  • Arizona Coyotes – The Vegas home opener may be the best ever from a new NHL franchise and the Coyotes ensured that it would be remembered for a long time. The players staying after they lost to salute the Vegas crowd was unexpectedly epic. This team has class, and while they may still not be good for another year or two, they’re doing everything right. [ABC Arizona]

  • Buffalo Sabres – It’s the battle of the two basement dwellers on Thursday night as the Sabres travel to San Jose. The Sabres will be more desperate than the Sharks, as I doubt the veteran laden Sharks are worried about an 0-2 start but the Sabres have given up 15 goals in their 0-2-1 start. Can Buffalo afford another season amidst the bottom of the league? [Sabre Noise]

  • San Jose Sharks – The Sharks sit last in the standings (albeit after only two games so it means next to nothing) so instead of focusing on a couple loses, just look at this poodle that got a San Jose Sharks makeover. It’ll make everything better, I promise. [Sporting News]

Thanks for reading! Be sure to checkout our podcast here!

The delay of game penalty for a failed offside challenge has at least softened the drudgery of sitting through a challenge every game in fear of being put on the penalty kill for 2 minutes after already having given up a goal. However, it seems as though the punishment may not fit the crime. A skater does not decide whether his coach challenges a play, but he ends up in the penalty box to serve the penalty. There is some precedence for sacrificial penalty serving whenever a goaltender commits a penalty, but its understandable why that goalie cannot end up in the box. It would be ridiculous to have to have an empty net for a couple minutes while on the penalty kill.

The coach’s failed offside challenge delay of game penalty should end with a different type of punishment. Instead of a skater ending up in the box, the head coach should serve the penalty. Make him do the walk of shame across the ice and take a seat for 2 minutes or less. There would be no better way to keep coaches from using the challenge then this…

Ask your questions & share your feedback

Scroll to top